Monday, October 10, 2011

And the Nobel goes to...

Since the past couple of posts have been a bit heavy I'd like to discuss the Nobel Peace Prize winners. A little delayed since the winners were announced in early October. 


Ellen Johnson Sirleaf the president of Liberia, Leymah Gbowee of Liberia and native Yemeni Tawakkul Karman are this years winners of the Nobel Peace Prize. According to the Nobel Prize website, the three women were awarded with this years prize "for their non-violent struggle for the safety of women and for women's rights to full participation in peace building work." 


I never knew how the selections are done so here is a graphic to explain:
nomination process


Only 'qualified nominators' are allowed to submit the names of people worthy of the prize. Qualified meaning members of international courts, national assemblies, governments of states, university rectors, professors (of social sciences, history, philosophy, law and theology, sorry Gaylord professors), persons who have been awarded prizes and so on. 


Back to the 2011 winners.


Sirleaf studied at the University of Colorado and received her masters degree in public administration at Harvard. When she returned to Liberia she served as Minister of Finance. After a violent military coup led by Samuel Kayon Doe that ended up with the President of Liberia and several other members being executed. Sirleaf chose exile in Kenya. In 1985, Sirleaf began to campaign against Doe during the elections and was forced into house arrest. She was then sentenced to prison but only spent a short time serving and then left as an exile again.From 1992-97 she worked as assistant administrator and director of the United Nations Development Program Regional Bureau for Africa. She returned in 1997 to run for presidency but was charged with treason. It wasn't until 2005 that she was inaugurated as President of Liberia. She is the first elected female president of Liberia and the first elected female leader on the continent. She is up for reelection this year. 



Gbowee is the executive director of the Women Peace and Security Network Africa and is also a founding member of the Women in Peacebuilding Program/West African Network for Peacebuilding.  In her work she gather several hundred women from 9 of 15 counties in Liberia for creating peace in the nation. Previous international honors include the Blue Ribbon Peace Award given to her by the Women's Leadership Board at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government. Gbowee,along with other Liberian women were given Profiles in Courage Award by the Kennedy Library Foundation.The Peace Prize highlights her major break in in mobilizing women across many divides to end civil wars in Liberia. She is also the central character in the 2008 documentary "Pray the Devil Back to Hell."

Tawakkul Karman



"We want to show the world that women can do everything." -Tawakkul Karman
Tawakkul Karman is a journalist and activist from Yemen. Karman is both the founder and chairwoman of Women Journalists without Chains and has worked to secure journalistic freedom for Yemen. Threats of violence have reached not only Karman but her family as well. Women Journalists without Chains have continued to be denied a newspaper license as another sign of opposition from the Yemeni government. Karman has also produced the "Semi-Annual Press Freedom Report" which shows increased violence against Yemeni Journalists. She continuously leads journalists to protest bans on news alerts and other protests against government policies. 
      

Out of 101 Nobel Peace Prize awards, 15 have gone to women. 

Thursday, September 22, 2011

#RIPTROYDAVIS

According to Amnesty International, 2/3 of the world has abolished the death penalty in law or practice. Guess where the United States is? We are among the 58 countries that 'retain' the death penalty for 'ordinary crimes.' Our friends in the capital punishment world include: Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Zimbabwe, Egypt, Somalia, Sudan, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Uganda, Syria, Sierra Leone and plenty more. It's nice to think that we are among countries that really value human rights. 


"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed..."


The right to life is a common thread not only in our Declaration of Independence but in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. The Bible, (since we are in Oklahoma I feel it is my duty to add a nugget of religion into my argument), while it does not forbid or restrict capital punishment, it does say that only a higher power can judge. What about this forgiveness stuff as well?  Lets pull some philosophy in here just for good measure, the Golden Rule, treat others the way you would have others treat you. The Golden Rule pops up in every major religion so that has some weight behind right? 


Troy Davis was executed last night after being charged with the 1989 murder of a police officer in Georgia. I remember coming to OU my freshman year and joining Amnesty International. The very first thing that was discussed was Troy Davis. This was four years ago. The battle to prove Troy Davis' innocence and abolish the death penalty has been going on for quite sometime. Despite the national and international protest against his execution, the U.S. Supreme Court denied clemency to Troy Davis yesterday and as a result, possibly an innocent man was executed. 


His final words before he was executed was, "The incident that night was not my fault.  I did not have a gun.  I did not personally kill your son, father or brother.  I am innocent.  Look deeper into this case, so you can really find the truth.  For those who are about to take my life, may god have mercy upon your souls and may god bless your souls."


I think last night marked an important change in the United States.

Troy Davis' case made it painfully obvious about the injustices in the world. The evidence against Davis was weak at best. There was no DNA linking Davis. The gun was never found. 7 witnesses recanted. According to the Guardian, "Davis had said he wanted his case to set an example "that the death penalty in this country needs to end. They call it execution; we call it murder." 

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

What can we expect?

Almost a year ago, El Diario de Jaurez, published a question pointed to drug cartels in Mexico.

 What do you want from us?

This simple question had my mind spinning. Why were these journalists dedicated to exposing the truth of their city asking what these criminals wanted? I was immediately conflicted. I have family in Mexico that have seen the violence that the drug cartels and government have caused. Reading stories written by Mexican journalists I saw them as the bravest and most dedicated of people so when I read the headline I was confused. These journalists knew what they signed on for. They knew going into it that the drug cartels spare no one, so how could they expect no retaliation? 

Honestly though, what level of protection can we as journalists expect? How can we expect powerful and accurate pieces to be produced for the public if the pressures of death are looming over their heads? 

Mexico's reaction to this was to create an agreement between media outlets. This agreement outlines what journalists covering drug cartels must follow.

"1) Take a stance against violence: […] the media should never, under any circumstance, justify actions and arguments of organized crime and terrorism […].
2) Do not become an involuntary spokesman for organized crime: […] the media should avoid using the language used by delinquents […]. Prevent that delinquents or presumed ones turn into victims or public heroes […].
3) Provide context for information: Present information in its correct context and in perspective […]
4) Specifically attribute responsibility for crimes: […] In the event that any State action to combat organized crime falls into excesses, is outside the law or violates human rights, it should always be recorded […] when the State action is performed within the law, it should be clear that violence is the product of criminal groups."


In nation's that human rights are being denied and there is constant conflict, journalists are facing oppression and violence. Journalists are faced with the decision to do their job but with constraints in limits. Journalists across the world are facing this problem. In this past year alone we've lost great reporters and photographers. 


I guess what I'm trying to say (and in turn work out how I feel), as journalists we have a duty to report the facts, but does that mean whatever the costs? Where do we draw the line and do we ASK the group that is destroying not only how journalists work but a society as a whole what they expect and want from us? How can journalists ask that and still fulfill their job as reporters of the facts?  


I still haven't decided how I feel about the situation. There is no real answer except that journalists will continue doing their job despite the risks. Mexico has proved that. Libya has proved that. Pakistan has proved that. So many other countries have proved that when faced with a human rights dilemma that silences the voices of it's media and country(wo)men, people will continue to spread the message. 

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Loopholes

Congress, The White House Blog
             International Human Rights law was created in 1945 with the birth of the United Nations. Since it’s creation, hundreds of treaties have been created dealing with human rights issues across the world.  The process of creating treaties is often very time consuming. Even when the treaty has been created, a country or state can create a list of reservations, meaning that the country or state will not follow certain articles of a treaty. The United States is one of those nations that almost always has a list of reservations in regards to human rights treaties. It is common knowledge that the Constitution of the United States is the supreme document in law. Nothing can contradict it or change it unless an amendment is passed. Some reservations created for treaties are done so to uphold the Constitution above any law ratified through treaties. An example of this is a reservation made when the U.S. was adopting the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

            “The Senate’s advice and consent is subject to the following reservations:
(1) That Article 20 does not authorize or require legislation or other action by the United States that would restrict the right of free speech and association protected by the Constitution and laws of the United States.”

            Article 20 in the ICCPR is not intended to limit freedom of speech, well it is but against speech that is discriminatory.

            Article 20 of the ICCPR:
1.     Any propaganda for war shall be prohibited by law.
2.     Any advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination hostility or violence shall be prohibited by law.
           
            This is one reservation that I agree with. Limiting speech and expression will only lead to more problems. Unfortunately we have to deal with the crazies now, but at least everyone has the right.
            The part that gets me about creating reservations, declarations and understandings for treaties is that the United States is making a loophole for itself, well mainly a loophole for congress. The point of ratifying a human rights treaty is a) to protect our rights and liberties, and b) for the courts to interpret and uphold the laws. When a reservation is made its congress that is interpreting and changing the laws. An example of this is the reservation made against another article of the ICCPR.
      
Loophole Hunters
Stoppaydaypredators.org
            “That the United States considers itself bound by Article 7 to the extent that “cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment” means the cruel and unusual treatment of punishment prohibited by the Fifth, Eighth and/or Fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution of the United States.”

            What Congress is doing though that reservation is adopting the article but under the terms of the Constitution, meaning the original intent and purpose of the treaty is void. So when someone goes to court and calls upon the ICCPR as evidence of inhumane treatment, it is then judged in terms of what domestic law states and not the practice of what every other nation that adopted the ICCPR. Also it should be noted that every human rights treaty that the United States enters into is non self-executing. This means that it does not automatically go into domestic law and if Congress doesn’t enact it then the courts cannot uphold the laws. Again, this transfers the power to congress, which does not keep the treaty’s intentions pure or independent from political factions.

What do you think?