Saturday, November 19, 2011
Social Media & Journalism
Humans are narcissists. We love to talk about ourselves and share things that are generally mundane with people. Social media allows for that. We share our feelings, emotions and daily happenings on Facebook. So I'm not surprised that journalists turned to social media to track down sources and to use that information for stories. It's done even more so today than in 2009 when the Annie Le story broke. Ethically speaking, Bailey should have told Del Rocco from the get go that she was a journalists and that she would like to use the information she learned on her Facebook page for a story. I think the way the Independent handled the information they were receiving as the story developed was very good. They were careful not to affect the publics perception of the case and to ensure that the investigation wasn't damaged. The Society of Professional Journalists state that journalists should consider certain things when it comes to the ethics of the job. One of them is to minimize harm and I think that the Independent was working that way. Bailey admitted later that she should have told Del Rocco that she was a journalists when she had added her as a friend. I feel that if someone refuses to be interviewed it goes without saying that you shouldn't use information on their Facebook page. Although people should be more wary of what they post on Facebook. Nothing leaves the Internet once it's posted and privacy on the Internet is somewhat limited.
Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Pope in a Sex Club
I think we are all very aware of the scandals within the Catholic Church, (insert Catholic priest joke). On September 13, 2011 the sex abuse victims asked the International Criminal Courts to charge Pope Benedict XVI with crimes against humanity. When I read that I honestly thought, what the hell? I'm not here to defend the actions of the men who sexually abused members of their congregations. Not even close. I'm a cradle Catholic, but my brother calls me a cafeteria Catholic. I pick and choose what I believe in. Clever isn't it?
People get up in arms when it comes to the Catholic Church, but my question is how many Baptist Ministers, Presbyterians, Buddhists and Imam's have done terrible things to the people that trust them? The Catholic Church represents a huge group of people and has a lot of influence across the world. The sex scandals alone cost the Vatican $700 million. (Makes me wish I had applied for a scholarship from the Church). Some have also stated that more charges are brought against the Catholic Church because of the amount of money and influence they have. Whether this is true or not, I don't know. However I could see how this is true for some, small amount of cases. Maybe. (People are opportunists and this is America right?)
The charges being brought against the Church are most likely to raise awareness to the sex abuse within the clergy. I think people are starting to take notice.
Recently a Catholic bishop in Kansas City is being charged for failing to report sex abuse within his diocese. This is unprecedented because charges are rarely raised against the hierarchical level and normally just the perpetrator. The clergy for the most part has the bad habit of playing priest shuffle (which stems from historical Canon law that made it difficult for bishops to defrock a priest) but it seems that more and more people are being held responsible.
The LA Times reports that it is uncertain whether charges like this will begin to pop up in other regions or if it is only for this case.
"What remains to be seen is whether the indictment of Bishop Robert Finn will be an isolated event or will encourage prosecutors elsewhere to investigate allegations of coverup against members of the church leadership.
The charges being brought against the Church are most likely to raise awareness to the sex abuse within the clergy. I think people are starting to take notice.
Recently a Catholic bishop in Kansas City is being charged for failing to report sex abuse within his diocese. This is unprecedented because charges are rarely raised against the hierarchical level and normally just the perpetrator. The clergy for the most part has the bad habit of playing priest shuffle (which stems from historical Canon law that made it difficult for bishops to defrock a priest) but it seems that more and more people are being held responsible.
The LA Times reports that it is uncertain whether charges like this will begin to pop up in other regions or if it is only for this case.
"What remains to be seen is whether the indictment of Bishop Robert Finn will be an isolated event or will encourage prosecutors elsewhere to investigate allegations of coverup against members of the church leadership.
Prosecutors announced Friday that Finn had been charged with a single misdemeanor count of failure to report child abuse after he allegedly learned — but failed to tell authorities — that a priest in his diocese had a laptop computer containing hundreds of images of child pornography. Finn's diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph was also charged.
"I can assure you that this has nothing — nothing — to do with the Catholic faith," Jackson County Prosecutor Jean Peters Baker said in announcing the indictments. "This is about the facts of this case, and this is about protecting children."
The exposure that the Survivors Network have brought to the international courts will no doubt be dismissed, but what it does do is raise awareness of the problem. My issue is that the Catholic Church always ends up being the sexual abuser. I'd like to see the rates within other communities. Sexual abuse is not a phenomenon to the Catholic clergy. I think there needs to be more aid to the victims and more charges being raised against specific members of the clergy that are abusers. I think that the charges brought to the ICC no doubt have raised awareness, but I think detrimental to the positive works done within the Church. It isn't fair to paint a whole group with guilt when only individuals are to blame.
Media Blackout, Social Media firestorm at Zuccotti Park
![]() |
| "Cops just violently shoved me away as I tried to shoot this man in a stretcher being loaded into ambulance" --@JoshHarkinson |
Whether you agree with the 99% or not, I should hope that the right to free speech and assembly would be protected. The right is protected by domestic and international law. Despite this, protestors found themselves being forcibly removed from the park in New York City. Josh Harkinson, a writer for Mother Jones magazine, witnessed and tweeted the police raid as it happened. With the media being blacked out, journalists and citizens took to social media to document the event and raise awareness of the police raid. Harkinson tweeted that protestors were resisting peacefully and that the police were rounding up the media in a pen away from Zuccotti Park. Tweet after tweet, Harkinson and many others shed light on Zuccotti Park where no one else could.

@tedalexandro was also constantly updating his followers with the location of the protestors after being evicted from the park. He commented to his followers after the eviction about the gross violations of the 1st amendment, tweeting, "Helluva night for 1st Amendment: Protects the freedom of religion, speech, the press, as well as the right to assemble/petition govt. #OWS" and "No matter how you feel about #OWS, I hope the absolute disregard for freedom of the press during tonight's raid on the park gives you pause."
Another account by D.C. reporter, @gzornick, stated over 10 hours ago, "NYC authorities clearly feel #OWS eviction is just and reasonable. That's why they are doing it at 2am and barring all press." James West, another writer for Mother Jones magazine, has now begun using Twitter to crowd-source photos and information from those who were at the park when the NYPD raid began.
According to the Huffington Post, "The surprise raid on the Occupy Wall Street encampment included an aggressive, sometimes violent approach to the journalists covering the event." The journalists that were forced or kept out of the area began, like protestors and citizens, tweeting with the hashtag #mediablackout. Some journalists were reportedly arrested as well, yet Mayor Michael Bloomberg stated that "Journalists were barred from covering the raid to protect members of the press and to prevent a situation from getting worse." NPR reporter Julie Walker and New York Times reporter Jared Malsin were arrested and a city councilman Ydanis Rodriguez was beaten.
Education reporter for NY1, Lindsey Christ, tweeted "Reporters/photogs being thrown to ground and pushed to wall if they get in front of the wrong officer. Other officers calm and polite."
![]() |
| "NYPD officer lines are four deep at the northwest corner of Zuccotti #OWS" --Andrew Katz, @Katz 12:53pm Nov. 15, 2011 |
The courts are now dealing with the issue. Follow Nick Pinto for updates on Twitter from inside the courthouse.
This is the most recent photo that has popped up on my Twitter feed. -->
What do you think, excessive or warranted? Was Bloomberg justified in forcing out the demonstrators? How about the media blackout?
UPDATE: Check out this blog on Reuters. Very interesting post on the events that happened and some great shots.
UPDATE 11:20pm 11/16/11: This is really neat--> http://maps.occupy.net/
Monday, November 14, 2011
Silenced: Ai Weiwei and the People
![]() |
| Ai Weiwei tossing his ceramic sunflower seeds into the air. Photo by: The Guardian |
Weiwei has been very critical against the Chinese government when it comes to human rights issues. The Telegraph published a timeline of his movement at the beginning of this month:
"2009: publishes a list of 5,835 names of students killed in the 2008 Sichuan earthquake on his blog. This lead to his blog being shut down and he claims he was detained and beaten by police for trying to testify on behalf of his fellow investigator, Tan Zuoren, about the poor construction that lead to student casualties in the earthquake.
March 2010: takes part in an event entitled "Digital Activism in China" hosted by the Paley Media Centre in New York.
Nov 2010: placed under house arrest by the Chinese police to allegedly prevent the planned demonstrations against the demolition of his Shanghai studio.
April, 2011: arrested at Peking Airport just before catching a flight to Hong Kong.
June 2011: released on bail after close to three months' detention on charges of tax evasion. Chinese authorities said he confessed to tax evasion but his family denies he evaded any taxes. They say he is being targeted for criticizing the Communist government October 2011: Ordered to pay 15m yuan in back taxes and fines. Ai says he won't pay until his design company's account books are returned and he discusses the matter with his former office manager and accountant. He has not been allowed to see them."
It isn't surprising that the Chinese government would silence Ai Weiwei. They certainly don't have a problem with shutting people down. In August, the Chinese government released a draft of the amendment changes that they were proposing that would allow Chinese police officers to perform secret arrests and investigations.
GlobalVoices posted anonymous commentary along with their story:
"Despite the negotiation among the public security, procuratorial and peoples' courts organs, the lawyers and the scholars, there are still some hidden problems in some of the clauses. For example, clause 84 has become the focus of public attention: “Upon arrest, the suspect should be sent to a detention center within 24 hours. With the exception that the police are unable to contact the suspect's family, or if the case involves national security, terrorist activities or serious criminal activities, and if the process would obstruct the investigation, the police should notify the family members within 24 hours regarding the reason and the location of the detention.” Such exceptions also appear in “house arrest”, “arrest” and other coercion measures.… It implies that under the above mentioned circumstances, the suspects could “be detained according to the law” and their family members would not receive any notification. This is the clause that violates fundamental human rights and that the public finds most scornful.”
Another recent example of Chinese censorship is the social networking site, Sina Weibo, shutting down German newspaper, Deutsche Welle's account. The technical term for what happened to the German account is "re-incarnating" as punishment for posting "sensitive topics." This basically means that the account holder must recreate their account and accumulate followers back from zero.
![]() |
| I thought this was humorous. Here's the link: http://chinachannel.fffff.at/ |
For more on Ai Weiwei click on his name...
Also, some of you may find this interesting, China: Enforced Disappearances.
Also, some of you may find this interesting, China: Enforced Disappearances.
#TwitTerrorista
The revolutions springing up from Arab countries the past few months has been spurred on by social media. The oppressed peoples of the Libya, Egypt, Iran and Syria turned to social media to reach out to the world and fight back against the governments. Social media was their window to freedom and the fire to their revolution.
Mexican's have also faced media censure and oppression. Unlike other countries, Mexican's have been silenced not only by government bodies but by the powerful and violent drug cartels that rule the nation.
Lorne Matalon, a Mexican journalist for Public Radio International's the World spoke about the censorship to students at Gaylord college.
According to the OU Daily, "He said reporters in Mexico every day ask themselves if the story they’re pursuing is worth the risk — the risk being their lives — because the cartels are watching, which is why some newspapers have resorted to self-censoring, meaning they only print stories unrelated to cartel activities, and any stories published about the cartels are direct government statements."
With journalists censoring themselves, citizens have taken the role of information providers into their own hands through social media. Like the professional journalists, their lives are now at stake.
Citizens have taken to using Twitter and blogs to share information about the drug cartels that have taken control of their country. According to the New York Times, Mexican citizens will use specific hash tags on Twitter about specific violent events in an area so that everyone know where the violence is, when it happened and who was possibly involved. Cartels have retaliated by dumping bodies in public areas and sending messages to those using crowd-sourcing methods to keep tabs on the drug world. Although the facts on these cases are still being debated on whether it is corrupt government officials or drug cartels carrying out these social media murders, innocent people are still being killed.
I've already discussed this topic before, although from the journalist perspective, but am I the only one that feels that there is a lot of talk about the drug war but no action? Everyday I hear more and more about the violence and corruption in Mexico. Perhaps this topic hits home a bit more for me than others, but I think it should hit home to more people. The United States shares more than a border with Mexico. Also, this drug war may affect Mexicans more because they see and feel the effects of the violence, but where do the drugs go? Who are the consumers?
I recommend reading this post on The Lede by Robert Mackey. The information he has compiled is very interesting.
What are your thoughts?
Mexican's have also faced media censure and oppression. Unlike other countries, Mexican's have been silenced not only by government bodies but by the powerful and violent drug cartels that rule the nation.
![]() |
| A man and a woman were found hanging over a busy motor way with signs attached to them stating, "This will happen to all the internet snitches. Be warned, we've go our eye on you. Signed, Z." |
According to the OU Daily, "He said reporters in Mexico every day ask themselves if the story they’re pursuing is worth the risk — the risk being their lives — because the cartels are watching, which is why some newspapers have resorted to self-censoring, meaning they only print stories unrelated to cartel activities, and any stories published about the cartels are direct government statements."
With journalists censoring themselves, citizens have taken the role of information providers into their own hands through social media. Like the professional journalists, their lives are now at stake.
![]() |
I've already discussed this topic before, although from the journalist perspective, but am I the only one that feels that there is a lot of talk about the drug war but no action? Everyday I hear more and more about the violence and corruption in Mexico. Perhaps this topic hits home a bit more for me than others, but I think it should hit home to more people. The United States shares more than a border with Mexico. Also, this drug war may affect Mexicans more because they see and feel the effects of the violence, but where do the drugs go? Who are the consumers?
I recommend reading this post on The Lede by Robert Mackey. The information he has compiled is very interesting.
What are your thoughts?
Monday, October 10, 2011
And the Nobel goes to...
Since the past couple of posts have been a bit heavy I'd like to discuss the Nobel Peace Prize winners. A little delayed since the winners were announced in early October.
Ellen Johnson Sirleaf the president of Liberia, Leymah Gbowee of Liberia and native Yemeni Tawakkul Karman are this years winners of the Nobel Peace Prize. According to the Nobel Prize website, the three women were awarded with this years prize "for their non-violent struggle for the safety of women and for women's rights to full participation in peace building work."

Sirleaf studied at the University of Colorado and received her masters degree in public administration at Harvard. When she returned to Liberia she served as Minister of Finance. After a violent military coup led by Samuel Kayon Doe that ended up with the President of Liberia and several other members being executed. Sirleaf chose exile in Kenya. In 1985, Sirleaf began to campaign against Doe during the elections and was forced into house arrest. She was then sentenced to prison but only spent a short time serving and then left as an exile again.From 1992-97 she worked as assistant administrator and director of the United Nations Development Program Regional Bureau for Africa. She returned in 1997 to run for presidency but was charged with treason. It wasn't until 2005 that she was inaugurated as President of Liberia. She is the first elected female president of Liberia and the first elected female leader on the continent. She is up for reelection this year.
Gbowee is the executive director of the Women Peace and Security Network Africa and is also a founding member of the Women in Peacebuilding Program/West African Network for Peacebuilding. In her work she gather several hundred women from 9 of 15 counties in Liberia for creating peace in the nation. Previous international honors include the Blue Ribbon Peace Award given to her by the Women's Leadership Board at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government. Gbowee,along with other Liberian women were given Profiles in Courage Award by the Kennedy Library Foundation.The Peace Prize highlights her major break in in mobilizing women across many divides to end civil wars in Liberia. She is also the central character in the 2008 documentary "Pray the Devil Back to Hell."
Tawakkul Karman
Tawakkul Karman is a journalist and activist from Yemen. Karman is both the founder and chairwoman of Women Journalists without Chains and has worked to secure journalistic freedom for Yemen. Threats of violence have reached not only Karman but her family as well. Women Journalists without Chains have continued to be denied a newspaper license as another sign of opposition from the Yemeni government. Karman has also produced the "Semi-Annual Press Freedom Report" which shows increased violence against Yemeni Journalists. She continuously leads journalists to protest bans on news alerts and other protests against government policies.
Ellen Johnson Sirleaf the president of Liberia, Leymah Gbowee of Liberia and native Yemeni Tawakkul Karman are this years winners of the Nobel Peace Prize. According to the Nobel Prize website, the three women were awarded with this years prize "for their non-violent struggle for the safety of women and for women's rights to full participation in peace building work."
I never knew how the selections are done so here is a graphic to explain:
Only 'qualified nominators' are allowed to submit the names of people worthy of the prize. Qualified meaning members of international courts, national assemblies, governments of states, university rectors, professors (of social sciences, history, philosophy, law and theology, sorry Gaylord professors), persons who have been awarded prizes and so on.
Back to the 2011 winners.
Gbowee is the executive director of the Women Peace and Security Network Africa and is also a founding member of the Women in Peacebuilding Program/West African Network for Peacebuilding. In her work she gather several hundred women from 9 of 15 counties in Liberia for creating peace in the nation. Previous international honors include the Blue Ribbon Peace Award given to her by the Women's Leadership Board at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government. Gbowee,along with other Liberian women were given Profiles in Courage Award by the Kennedy Library Foundation.The Peace Prize highlights her major break in in mobilizing women across many divides to end civil wars in Liberia. She is also the central character in the 2008 documentary "Pray the Devil Back to Hell."Tawakkul Karman
| "We want to show the world that women can do everything." -Tawakkul Karman |
Out of 101 Nobel Peace Prize awards, 15 have gone to women.
Thursday, September 22, 2011
#RIPTROYDAVIS
According to Amnesty International, 2/3 of the world has abolished the death penalty in law or practice. Guess where the United States is? We are among the 58 countries that 'retain' the death penalty for 'ordinary crimes.' Our friends in the capital punishment world include: Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Zimbabwe, Egypt, Somalia, Sudan, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Uganda, Syria, Sierra Leone and plenty more. It's nice to think that we are among countries that really value human rights. "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed..."

The right to life is a common thread not only in our Declaration of Independence but in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. The Bible, (since we are in Oklahoma I feel it is my duty to add a nugget of religion into my argument), while it does not forbid or restrict capital punishment, it does say that only a higher power can judge. What about this forgiveness stuff as well? Lets pull some philosophy in here just for good measure, the Golden Rule, treat others the way you would have others treat you. The Golden Rule pops up in every major religion so that has some weight behind right?
Troy Davis was executed last night after being charged with the 1989 murder of a police officer in Georgia. I remember coming to OU my freshman year and joining Amnesty International. The very first thing that was discussed was Troy Davis. This was four years ago. The battle to prove Troy Davis' innocence and abolish the death penalty has been going on for quite sometime. Despite the national and international protest against his execution, the U.S. Supreme Court denied clemency to Troy Davis yesterday and as a result, possibly an innocent man was executed. His final words before he was executed was, "The incident that night was not my fault. I did not have a gun. I did not personally kill your son, father or brother. I am innocent. Look deeper into this case, so you can really find the truth. For those who are about to take my life, may god have mercy upon your souls and may god bless your souls."
I think last night marked an important change in the United States.
Troy Davis' case made it painfully obvious about the injustices in the world. The evidence against Davis was weak at best. There was no DNA linking Davis. The gun was never found. 7 witnesses recanted. According to the Guardian, "Davis had said he wanted his case to set an example "that the death penalty in this country needs to end. They call it execution; we call it murder."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






